Sentimental Value
honestly, i don’t know yet what to say about this film. i need time. i need to sit with it longer before writing anything definitive. when i left the theater, i know i wasn’t thinking clearly. i was too influenced by how much of my own life i saw reflected on screen.
but i couldn’t stop thinking about tolstoy. about that opening line in Anna Karenina: “all happy families resemble one another, each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.” this film feels built entirely around that idea. not in a dramatic way, but in the accumulation of small unresolved things that never explode, just stay there.
what struck me most is how the film uses cinema itself as language. the narrative folds in on itself, and the past, the present, and future the performance overlapping, because memory doesn’t come with clean transitions. the editing feels like an insistent thought you can’t shut off. gustav’s film inside the film is a failed attempt at repair. he tries to organize trauma through art, to turn his absence as a father into meaning. it’s imperfect by design. and it makes sense that an american actress doesn’t quite belong there: she looks for logic, clarity, for just a netflix scrip. BUT this story demands lived experience and emotional residue.
the performances are AMAZING. and the house is PERFECT. the house is essential. that crack in the wall feels like the film quietly opening the set for us, exposing the family as if it were a stage. and the clean and cold cinematography keeps emotion at a distance, just enough to stop it from turning into melodrama.
i’m still unsure how i feel about the ending. whether it suggests acceptance or just another version of repetition. maybe both. that discomfort feels intentional.
PS: i laughed SO MUCH at the The Piano Teacher and Irreversible references. Joachim Trier’s humor is exactly what cinema needs.
#withbecca