Raging Bull
A grand, poetic tragedy about only being able to think of yourself and everyone else as a bag of meat. Every action, word, and thought in Jake LaMotta's life revolves around the body - pain, weight, sex, physical closeness - and he forces everyone in his life into this framework, often with violent results. On his first date with his eventual wife, he has nothing to actually say, spending most of the time coaxing her to move closer to him. And like the man with a hammer to whom every problem looks like a nail, whenever Jake is confronted with any problem that isn't purely physical, thanks to De Niro's absolutely faultless performance, you can practically see the gears in his head turning as he tries to work out what to do, before inevitably, again and again, simply turning to a threat, a beating, or a bizarre, hounding attempt at a kiss or hug. The ring is the only place where everything makes sense, and he there uses his body as a conduit, a blunt object through which to purge himself of the confusion of his interpersonal relationships, never to any useful end. He violently pummels an attractive young fighter out of jealousy, he lets himself get brutalized beyond recognition upon finally ruining his relationship with his brother, because the only way he knows how to express himself or to atone is through the physical. It goes without saying that the boxing scenes here are some of the best of any kind in cinematic history, with their frenzied, feral editing and unforgettable imagery and borderline surreal expressionism putting the audience squarely within Jake's POV every time.
The final 30 minutes of the film would almost be hilarious if they weren't so tragic, with Jake's own body finally having given up on him too, at last ruined by years of abuse just like everyone around him. As difficult a watch as this film is, one of the biggest laughs I've had so far in Scorsese's filmography is when LaMotta talks about the nightclub he's just bought and says "guess what I'm gonna call it? Guess!" like he's come up with some witty name he's super proud of, and then it cuts to a shot of the club: Jake La Motta's. What else, I guess? This is the first time in his life where he's pursued something that involves the intellect even slightly, and he is so out of his depth it's sad to watch. The insanely depressing sight of a fat, sloppy, sleazy Jake doing this aimless kind of half-standup to a crowd of pity-laughers feels like something close to what his personal hell would look like, and of course he's still using his body in the only way he can now, to force himself onto the young girls that patronize his club. When this finally lands him in trouble, it's again kind of darkly funny watching him try and fail spectacularly at dealing with a problem that even slightly involves the intellect, smashing up his championship belt to sell the jewels on it for bail money, not realizing the obvious fact that the intact belt would be worth much more. Once he finally does land in jail, all he can do is try to apply some physical sensation to the moment to punish himself - with no blunt objects to do the job, he simply hurls his body at the wall in a guttural agony. Not that it matters - his own personal hell still awaits even after he's released from jail, and the final scene proves it still hasn't occurred to him to even try to face anything on any level other than the physical, seeming genuinely confused by his misfortune and pumping himself up before what appears to be some kind of live monologuing performance by... shadowboxing. This is a new kind of punishment, that of humiliation.