

1938·Drama·1h 38m
7.1
★








A love story centered on the lives of three young German soldiers in the years following World War I. Their close friendship is strengthened by their shared love for the same woman who is dying of tuberculosis.
Directed by Frank Borzage
world war i

Trailer

IMDB
N/A
Where to Watch



Cast

Robert Taylor
Erich Lohkamp

Margaret Sullavan
Patricia Hollmann

Franchot Tone
Otto Koster

Robert Young
Gottfried Lenz

Guy Kibbee
Alfons

Lionel Atwill
Breuer

Henry Hull
Dr. Becker

Charley Grapewin
Local Doctor

Monty Woolley
Dr. Jaffe

Stanley Andrews
Officer giving toast (uncredited)

Jessie Arnold
Nurse at sanatorium (uncredited)

George Chandler
First comic with singer (uncredited)
Crew

Frank Borzage
Director

F. Scott Fitzgerald
Screenplay

Franz Waxman
Original Music Composer

Joseph Ruttenberg
Director of Photography

Joseph L. Mankiewicz
Producer

Cedric Gibbons
Art Direction

Douglas Shearer
Sound Director

Erich Maria Remarque
Book
Popular Reviews
6 reviews
Erik Olsson
7.0★ · 11/02/24

A curious case of a film, being the sole screen credit of F. Scott Fitzgerald and based on the book by Erich Maria Remarque, that I'm not really sure lives up to its potential. The film is backdropped by the post-WW1 strife of the Weimar Republic, but it doesn't feel like it meshes with main story well and isn't as direct as you'd expect from the author of All Quiet On The Western Front. But the central plot of the three friends and the woman they all care for is still engaging enough, largely due to Margaret Sullavan's heartbreaking performance. Curious to revisit this to see if I missed anything by being unfocused, or if the movie itself is unfocused.
A curious case of a film, being the sole screen credit of F. Scott Fitzgerald and based on the book by Erich Maria Remarque, that I'm not really sure lives up to its potential. The film is backdropped by the post-WW1 strife of the Weimar Republic, but it doesn't feel like it meshes with main story well and isn't as direct as you'd expect from the author of All Quiet On The Western Front. But the central plot of the three friends and the woman they all care for is still engaging enough, largely due to Margaret Sullavan's heartbreaking performance. Curious to revisit this to see if I missed anything by being unfocused, or if the movie itself is unfocused.
Joanna
8.0★ · 02/25/26

Sherbet
9.0★ · 01/25/26

Jackson
6.0★ · 11/02/25

v
8.0★ · 02/08/24
