I may be in the minority here, but I had such a great time with
The Strange Love of Martha Ivers. Directed by Lewis Millstone, 16 years after his Best Picture winning film
All Quiet on the Western Front, Millstone experiments with a noir genre that was raving in the 40’s. He secured a couple iconic noir actors with the queen herself, Barbara Stanwyck, and Kirk Douglas, who found his early success in the genre. This was also his debut role!
This was a great time from start to finish. Stanwyck plays her iconic femme fatale role, with great supporting performances from Van Heflin and Kirk Douglas. But a new face for me, and the real standout in this film was Lizabeth Scott. While not one of the major three characters with Ivers and her lovers, Scott plays stunning town guest, Toni, who falls in love with Van Helfin’s character, Sam. She becomes jealous of Martha after finding out Sam’s feelings for her. Scott really gives it her all here, and my favorite scene in the film is an emotional one, as Toni is caught crying after seeing Sam kiss Martha in her car. I also loved the way they lit and shot her, as if her beauty was radiating and glistening through the screen. It felt like the way Ingrid Bergman looked in
Casablanca. I’m definitely going to check out more of her work from her rather short career, although she still became a film noir icon.
Like most noirs, this film is overly dramatic, and its story can be seen to be a little ridiculous. But I actually loved this film for how bizarre it is. It’s rather heartbreaking opening scene sets the tone for the entire film. It’s an interesting look at the physical and emotional toll that comes with holding in a secret to that degree, that it’s bound to tear apart every party involved. Watching these characters reuniting years into the future is so interesting to watch unfold. And those melodramatic final 30 minutes solidify this as a memorable 40’s noir.
Barbara Stanwyck Ranked