

1947·Crime·1h 26m
7.1
★





A man is murdered, apparently by one of a group of soldiers just out of the army. But which one? And why?
Directed by Edward Dmytryk
army
film noir
antisemitism
soldier

Trailer

IMDB
N/A
Where to Watch



Cast

Robert Young
Finlay

Robert Mitchum
Peter Keeley

Robert Ryan
Montgomery

Gloria Grahame
Virginia "Ginny" Tremayne

Paul Kelly
The Man

Sam Levene
Samuels

Jacqueline White
Mary Mitchell

Steve Brodie
Floyd

George Cooper
Mitchell

Richard Benedict
Bill

Tom Keene
Detective

William Phipps
Leroy
Crew

Edward Dmytryk
Director

Roy Webb
Original Music Composer

Richard Brooks
Novel

Dore Schary
Presenter

C. Bakaleinikoff
Music Director

Albert S. D'Agostino
Art Direction
Popular Reviews
40 reviews
Ellie HolmesPRO
7.0★ · 06/05/26

This felt very progressive in many ways but also was quite predictable from early on and ik it wasnt a real whodunnit cos we are meant to work out whodunnit fairly quickly but still
This felt very progressive in many ways but also was quite predictable from early on and ik it wasnt a real whodunnit cos we are meant to work out whodunnit fairly quickly but still
Jack
6.0★ · 02/07/26

Not my cup of tea I guess
Not my cup of tea I guess
Kyra
7.0★ · 01/27/26

“I didn’t wanna hear nobody yell at nobody.” - the same sentiment I have when drinking and overstimulated at the function
Give me more scenes with Ginny’s simp. His dialogue scratches the itch for that classic noir-speak so well.
Give me more scenes with Ginny’s simp. His dialogue scratches the itch for that classic noir-speak so well.
“I didn’t wanna hear nobody yell at nobody.” - the same sentiment I have when drinking and overstimulated at the function
Give me more scenes with Ginny’s simp. His dialogue scratches the itch for that classic noir-speak so well.
Give me more scenes with Ginny’s simp. His dialogue scratches the itch for that classic noir-speak so well.
Ghoulie
8.0★ · 11/07/25

Ultra stylish and well-written little noir which replaces its (horrendous) source material's theme of gay-bashing with anti-semitism is obviously a very personal story for marginalized director Dmytryk. Performances are solid, including a wonderful turn by young Robert Ryan, and an all-around engaging story turn this long-forgotten film into quite the unheralded gem.
Thanks for reminding us of this, Criterion. Great pick for Noirvember.
Thanks for reminding us of this, Criterion. Great pick for Noirvember.
Ultra stylish and well-written little noir which replaces its (horrendous) source material's theme of gay-bashing with anti-semitism is obviously a very personal story for marginalized director Dmytryk. Performances are solid, including a wonderful turn by young Robert Ryan, and an all-around engaging story turn this long-forgotten film into quite the unheralded gem.
Thanks for reminding us of this, Criterion. Great pick for Noirvember.
Thanks for reminding us of this, Criterion. Great pick for Noirvember.
Mel RygusPRO
7.0★ · 11/01/25

Happy Noirvember to all who celebrate!
Starting off strong with a post-war film starring my #1 cleft chin in the biz- Robert Mitchum (and two other Roberts) firing off dialogue at 100 wpm. I didn’t ultimately love the story, I felt like it could have taken things farther and darker than it ultimately did, but overall a worthy start to a month full of chain smoking, finger waves and shadows, shadows and more shadows.
Starting off strong with a post-war film starring my #1 cleft chin in the biz- Robert Mitchum (and two other Roberts) firing off dialogue at 100 wpm. I didn’t ultimately love the story, I felt like it could have taken things farther and darker than it ultimately did, but overall a worthy start to a month full of chain smoking, finger waves and shadows, shadows and more shadows.
Happy Noirvember to all who celebrate!
Starting off strong with a post-war film starring my #1 cleft chin in the biz- Robert Mitchum (and two other Roberts) firing off dialogue at 100 wpm. I didn’t ultimately love the story, I felt like it could have taken things farther and darker than it ultimately did, but overall a worthy start to a month full of chain smoking, finger waves and shadows, shadows and more shadows.
Starting off strong with a post-war film starring my #1 cleft chin in the biz- Robert Mitchum (and two other Roberts) firing off dialogue at 100 wpm. I didn’t ultimately love the story, I felt like it could have taken things farther and darker than it ultimately did, but overall a worthy start to a month full of chain smoking, finger waves and shadows, shadows and more shadows.