City Girl backdrop
City Girl logo
1930·Drama·1h 28m
7.1
A waitress from Chicago falls in love with a man from rural Minnesota and marries him, with the intent of living a better life - but life on the farm has its own challenges.
Directed by F. W. Murnau
waitress
countryside
marriage crisis
pre-code
wheat

Cast

Charles Farrell
Charles Farrell
Lem Tustine
Mary Duncan
Mary Duncan
Kate
David Torrence
David Torrence
Lem's Father
Edith Yorke
Edith Yorke
Lem's Mother
Guinn 'Big Boy' Williams
Guinn 'Big Boy' Williams
Reaper
Anne Shirley
Anne Shirley
Marie Tustine
Tom McGuire
Tom McGuire
Matey
Richard Alexander
Richard Alexander
Mac
Ed Brady
Ed Brady
Reaper
Roscoe Ates
Roscoe Ates
Reaper
Marjorie Beebe
Marjorie Beebe
Waitress (uncredited)
Eddie Boland
Eddie Boland
Reaper (uncredited)

Crew

F. W. Murnau
F. W. Murnau
Director
Katherine Hilliker
Katherine Hilliker
Editor
William Fox
William Fox
Producer
A.H. Van Buren
A.H. Van Buren
Sound Director
Edgar G. Ulmer
Edgar G. Ulmer
Assistant Art Director

Popular Reviews

28 reviews
Hazel
Hazel
City Girl
So beautiful. Loved
So beautiful. Loved
Favorite
Comment
Sarah
Sarah
City Girl
Watched for the Anti-Criterion Challenge 2026: https://letterboxd.com/that1oboist/list/the-anti-criterion-challenge-2026/

14/52: Gregory Joseph’s Movies with Titles That Sound Like Soundcloud Rappers
Watched for the Anti-Criterion Challenge 2026: https://letterboxd.com/that1oboist/list/the-anti-criterion-challenge-2026/

14/52: Gregory Joseph’s Movies with Titles That Sound Like Soundcloud Rappers
Favorite
Comment
Mathias
Mathias
City Girl
Farming simulator 1930
Farming simulator 1930
Favorite
Comment
christy
christy
City Girl
Sunrise is definitely better but it's still good. I couldn't feel as much for the characters in this one. Farming scenes were very cool.
Sunrise is definitely better but it's still good. I couldn't feel as much for the characters in this one. Farming scenes were very cool.
Favorite
Comment
Da ginger Films
Da ginger Films
City Girl
A solid watch but one of Murnaus weaker outings 

Still a good film still a good film. I think I’ll never not like a Murnau film. His craft is unlike any other director imo and is one of my favourites but this is probably the least Murnau a Murnau films ever been.

The film is sort of a rehash of the Sunrise storyline but flipped. It starts off with the luscious life of the city then contrasts to the dark life of the countryside.

The film starts off as almost a romantic comedy but then turns into this dramatic romantic thriller I rlly liked the change and it worked well.

Yet again Murnau nails the differences in setting. This can be shown in many ways. The Vehicles used in the different settings, the busyness of the city to the emptiness and lack of people in the countryside. But my favourite part was the difference in score and costume Design. The different instruments used to represent the areas was rlly smart and the costumes are drastically different.

The film shows how greed gets in the way of love which I rather like.

But overall this films just solid. The romance in convincing the acting is solid and the message the film holds is solid enough.

Some parts of the film feel empty and the lack of Murnaus expressionist routes being implemented hurts he has gone full American cinema now. There was a few scenes but overall a very American experience which isn’t bad at all.

But this is a nice little romance film quite feel good tbf a very lovely ending to a overall solid film
A solid watch but one of Murnaus weaker outings 

Still a good film still a good film. I think I’ll never not like a Murnau film. His craft is unlike any other director imo and is one of my favourites but this is probably the least Murnau a Murnau films ever been.

The film is sort of a rehash of the Sunrise storyline but flipped. It starts off with the luscious life of the city then contrasts to the dark life of the countryside.

The film starts off as almost a romantic comedy but then turns into this dramatic romantic thriller I rlly liked the change and it worked well.

Yet again Murnau nails the differences in setting. This can be shown in many ways. The Vehicles used in the different settings, the busyness of the city to the emptiness and lack of people in the countryside. But my favourite part was the difference in score and costume Design. The different instruments used to represent the areas was rlly smart and the costumes are drastically different.

The film shows how greed gets in the way of love which I rather like.

But overall this films just solid. The romance in convincing the acting is solid and the message the film holds is solid enough.

Some parts of the film feel empty and the lack of Murnaus expressionist routes being implemented hurts he has gone full American cinema now. There was a few scenes but overall a very American experience which isn’t bad at all.

But this is a nice little romance film quite feel good tbf a very lovely ending to a overall solid film
Favorite
Comment
City Girl (1930) | Flick