Competing bakery owners, Faye McKenzie and Lydia Harper have been feuding for years with the Lake Shore County Harvest Festival’s annual pumpkin pie bake-off at the center of it all. The winner not only gets bragging rights and a trophy, but a substantial boost to her business, as well. This year, however, the women are passing the torch to their respective children, Casey and Sam, and when romantic sparks fly between them, this bake-off promises to be one to remember.
Directed by Steven R. Monroe
autumn
fall season
hallmark
Trailer
IMDB
N/A
Letterboxd
2.7 / 5
Where to Watch
Cast
Julie Gonzalo
Casey McArthy
Rico Aragon
Sam Harper
Michele Scarabelli
Faye McArthy
Jennifer Juniper Angeli
Lydia Harper
Peter Graham-Gaudreau
Reggie McArthy
Janet Glassford
Dee
Dolores Drake
Betty Lund
Rhonda Dent
Alisa McArthy
David Allan Pearson
Max Harper
David Stuart
Bob Dooley
Charles Zuckermann
Bartender
Meghan Gardiner
TV Host
Crew
Steven R. Monroe
Director
Nina Weinman
Writer
Michael G. Larkin
Executive Producer
Taylor Hill
Post Production Coordinator
Siân O'Byrne
Music Coordinator
Popular Reviews
5 reviews
Josie B
6.0★ · 11/01/25
It’s not November without a rewatch of one of my fave hallmark movies!
It’s not November without a rewatch of one of my fave hallmark movies!
valeria
2.8★ · 03/31/25
pelicula de lifetime core!! 🧡ojala los padres hubiesen tenido un romance homosexual😭Esas escapaditas dos veces al mes para “jugar al golf”, sin que esposa e hijos supieran MHMMMMPD:¿ Que tan bueno puede ser un pumpkin pie?!?
pelicula de lifetime core!! 🧡ojala los padres hubiesen tenido un romance homosexual😭Esas escapaditas dos veces al mes para “jugar al golf”, sin que esposa e hijos supieran MHMMMMPD:¿ Que tan bueno puede ser un pumpkin pie?!?
aly
5.0★ · 09/24/24
the romeo and juliet of pumpkin pie
first of all…i’m not sure the heartbreak ballad “lost boy” was the most appropriate choice to start off this movie about a bakery rivalry especially when the beginning scene was a pumpkin pie contest from years back
i knew there would be a plot twist with betty but i didn’t expect that !
the romeo and juliet of pumpkin pie
first of all…i’m not sure the heartbreak ballad “lost boy” was the most appropriate choice to start off this movie about a bakery rivalry especially when the beginning scene was a pumpkin pie contest from years back
i knew there would be a plot twist with betty but i didn’t expect that !
Abigail
3.0★ · 11/24/23
the dads having the golfing affair was the best part
the dads having the golfing affair was the best part
