

1946·Drama·1h 49m
7.0
★










When a woman’s twin sister is drowned, she assumes her identity in order to be close to the man she feels her sister took from her years before.
Directed by Curtis Bernhardt
island
based on novel or book
twin sister
massachusetts
painter
lighthouse keeper
sibling rivalry
twins
evil twin

Trailer

IMDB
N/A
Where to Watch



Cast

Bette Davis
Kate Bosworth / Patricia Bosworth

Glenn Ford
Bill Emerson

Dane Clark
Karnock

Walter Brennan
Eben Folger

Charles Ruggles
Freddie Linley

Bruce Bennett
Jack R. Talbot

Peggy Knudsen
Diedre

Esther Dale
Mrs. Johnson

Clara Blandick
Martha

Joan Winfield
Lucy

Bess Flowers
Department Store Shopper (uncredited)

Mary Servoss
Practical nurse (uncredited)
Crew

Curtis Bernhardt
Director

Catherine Turney
Screenplay

Max Steiner
Original Music Composer

Rudi Fehr
Editor

Ernest Haller
Director of Photography

Jack L. Warner
Executive Producer

Bette Davis
Producer

Jesse Hibbs
Assistant Director

Orry-Kelly
Costume Design
Popular Reviews
15 reviews
Sean
8.0★ · 05/31/26

Bette Davis twins?? I think my life is complete. For real though it’s crazy how good they were able to make the twins look now 80 years ago, there’s literally a Sinners shot in here of Bette passing a match to her twin and all through the movie I didn’t see a single flaw in the editing which is seriously high praise for the tech they had available back then. As for the story it’s just so much fun, I’m still not sure how to feel about that ending but the concept is one of the coolest I’ve seen from the golden age and the way the narrative flows through the first 90 minutes made that great concept even more entertaining to follow. I also find it interesting that neither of the twins we’re following is exactly morally upstanding, Pat isn’t a good person for obvious reasons and Katie’s crime is best explained by the title of the movie and the manipulation that followed, and there’s no doubt that Katie is the lesser evil there but I still find it interesting considering the “happy” ending and the hays code that usually prevented those for morally objectionable characters. It should be taken with a grain of salt because I’d say this about every other lead of hers but this is truly some of Bette’s best work, we didn’t see too much of the “evil” sister (which she of course nailed too and i DEFINITELY could’ve done with more of that character) but she was expectedly perfect in the spotlighted reserved yet emotional role that came with the “good” sister. I’d understand why and how some would take issue with parts of it especially with the ending which grabbed at heartstrings that didn’t really exist for me but A Stolen Life was really one of the most charming and fun movie experiences through the solid technical work, amazing story concept, and most importantly the powerhouse performance from the one and only Bette Davis.
Bette Davis twins?? I think my life is complete. For real though it’s crazy how good they were able to make the twins look now 80 years ago, there’s literally a Sinners shot in here of Bette passing a match to her twin and all through the movie I didn’t see a single flaw in the editing which is seriously high praise for the tech they had available back then. As for the story it’s just so much fun, I’m still not sure how to feel about that ending but the concept is one of the coolest I’ve seen from the golden age and the way the narrative flows through the first 90 minutes made that great concept even more entertaining to follow. I also find it interesting that neither of the twins we’re following is exactly morally upstanding, Pat isn’t a good person for obvious reasons and Katie’s crime is best explained by the title of the movie and the manipulation that followed, and there’s no doubt that Katie is the lesser evil there but I still find it interesting considering the “happy” ending and the hays code that usually prevented those for morally objectionable characters. It should be taken with a grain of salt because I’d say this about every other lead of hers but this is truly some of Bette’s best work, we didn’t see too much of the “evil” sister (which she of course nailed too and i DEFINITELY could’ve done with more of that character) but she was expectedly perfect in the spotlighted reserved yet emotional role that came with the “good” sister. I’d understand why and how some would take issue with parts of it especially with the ending which grabbed at heartstrings that didn’t really exist for me but A Stolen Life was really one of the most charming and fun movie experiences through the solid technical work, amazing story concept, and most importantly the powerhouse performance from the one and only Bette Davis.
Colton
6.0★ · 11/29/25

Were they making good movies in the year of our lord 1946?
Loses points for the ending, she shouldn’t have gotten with Emerson.
Gains points for the special effects on the twin scenes, looked better than some modern movies
Loses points for the ending, she shouldn’t have gotten with Emerson.
Gains points for the special effects on the twin scenes, looked better than some modern movies
Were they making good movies in the year of our lord 1946?
Loses points for the ending, she shouldn’t have gotten with Emerson.
Gains points for the special effects on the twin scenes, looked better than some modern movies
Loses points for the ending, she shouldn’t have gotten with Emerson.
Gains points for the special effects on the twin scenes, looked better than some modern movies
El
3.6★ · 06/24/25

bill when I catch you bill…
bill when I catch you bill…
Nicky
7.0★ · 06/12/25

BRUH I HAD HIGH HOPES FOR BILL , I really really liked him and he seemed like a good guy since he’s a loser alone in a lighthouse but he didn’t think twice in choosing pat over Katie EVEN THOUGH HE ACTUALLY GOT TO KNOW KATIE
it was very interesting though , I’d probably watch again
it was very interesting though , I’d probably watch again
BRUH I HAD HIGH HOPES FOR BILL , I really really liked him and he seemed like a good guy since he’s a loser alone in a lighthouse but he didn’t think twice in choosing pat over Katie EVEN THOUGH HE ACTUALLY GOT TO KNOW KATIE
it was very interesting though , I’d probably watch again
it was very interesting though , I’d probably watch again
AnotherplacePRO
6.0★ · 05/11/25

Bette Davis is incredible. Unfortunately just not my cup of tea, really ought to start watching more stuff from this era though.
Bette Davis is incredible. Unfortunately just not my cup of tea, really ought to start watching more stuff from this era though.