Newly-discovered facts, court records and speculation are used to elaborate the true love story and murder mystery of the most notorious unsolved murder case in New York history.
Directed by Andrew Jarecki
new york city
1970s
difficult childhood
suspicion of murder
childhood trauma
based on true story
overbearing father
real estate
business tycoon
1980s
wealth differences
missing wife
wealthy family
loss of mother
disapproving parent
family pressure
Rank
#143 in 2010·#6090 overall
Trailer
IMDB
N/A
Where to Watch
Cast
Ryan Gosling
David Marks
Kirsten Dunst
Katie Marks
Frank Langella
Sanford Marks
Lily Rabe
Deborah Lehrman
Philip Baker Hall
Malvern Bump
Michael Esper
Daniel Marks
Diane Venora
Janice Rizzo
Nick Offerman
Jim McCarthy
Kristen Wiig
Lauren Fleck
Stephen Kunken
Todd Fleck
John Cullum
Richard Panatierre
Maggie Kiley
Mary McCarthy
Crew
Andrew Jarecki
Director
Marc Smerling
Writer
Rob Simonsen
Original Music Composer
Michael Seresin
Director of Photography
Harvey Weinstein
Executive Producer
Andrew Jarecki
Producer
Marc Smerling
Producer
Michael London
Producer
Bob Weinstein
Executive Producer
Janice Williams
Executive Producer
Bruna Papandrea
Producer
Susan Jacobs
Music Supervisor
Popular Reviews
317 reviews
Thomas
5.0★ · 05/26/26
Can’t believe Ryan Gosling was The Bay Harbor Butcher
If I would have finished this movie in one day I would have probs given this 2 1/2 stars ngl 😭 Um truly hard to explain how I felt about this other than the ending was such a nothing burger I’m sorry 💔 But it was good, yeah it was good…
If I would have finished this movie in one day I would have probs given this 2 1/2 stars ngl 😭 Um truly hard to explain how I felt about this other than the ending was such a nothing burger I’m sorry 💔 But it was good, yeah it was good…
Iove miller
7.0★ · 06/16/26
drained the life out of that poor girl💔
drained the life out of that poor girl💔
Heyis
6.0★ · 06/12/26
I'm genuinely scared of Ryan as David Marks. His' acting in this movie is so scary. This movie once again reminds me to be careful choosing a choose partner, because people could be psychopaths and you won't know until you live with them.
I'm genuinely scared of Ryan as David Marks. His' acting in this movie is so scary. This movie once again reminds me to be careful choosing a choose partner, because people could be psychopaths and you won't know until you live with them.
