In an attempt to remind her family of their privilege and help them bond, Ms. Anna Barker invites Pilgrim reenactors to stay with them over Thanksgiving. When the “actors” refuse to break character, the Barker family learns that there is such a thing as too much gratitude.
Directed by Marcus Dunstan
holiday
thanksgiving
pilgrim
murder
serial killer
family
actor
psychological horror
holiday horror
IMDB
N/A
Letterboxd
2.6 / 5
Where to Watch
Cast
Reign Edwards
Cody
Beth Curry
Katherine
Antonio Raul Garcia
Tate
Peter Giles
Ethan
Courtney Henggeler
Anna
Elyse Levesque
Patience
Kerr Smith
Shane
Taj Speights
Finn
Crew
Marcus Dunstan
Director
Marcus Dunstan
Writer
Patrick Melton
Writer
Jason Blum
Executive Producer
Popular Reviews
27 reviews
Dylan S
3.0★ · 11/24/25
“I wish this whole thing would backfire in her stupid face.”
This is why you don’t mess around with wishbones. Who invites a random stranger inside their home to stay a couple of nights? This whole family sucks. Midsommar but it’s an American Pilgrim cult instead. The camera was moving too much for my liking—just stay still sometimes. The concept was good but the execution wasn’t.
“I wish this whole thing would backfire in her stupid face.”
This is why you don’t mess around with wishbones. Who invites a random stranger inside their home to stay a couple of nights? This whole family sucks. Midsommar but it’s an American Pilgrim cult instead. The camera was moving too much for my liking—just stay still sometimes. The concept was good but the execution wasn’t.
Zoey Fetters
6.0★ · 11/30/24
"did we just murder?... as a family?!"
"did we just murder?... as a family?!"
The
7.0★ · 11/28/24
Pretty good for a Hulu movie. The direction really succeeds in making up for how small the scale is in a way some might find annoying but it’s so much better than just pretending the Hulu style guide is good enough without putting some relish on it.
Usual issue of pulling every punch and there’s essentially 3 cast members that can act.
Pretty good for a Hulu movie. The direction really succeeds in making up for how small the scale is in a way some might find annoying but it’s so much better than just pretending the Hulu style guide is good enough without putting some relish on it.
Usual issue of pulling every punch and there’s essentially 3 cast members that can act.
